Fodor's Expert Review Hillside Supply & Price Buster
Hillside is probably the largest store on Long Island and the ideal place to stock up if you're self-catering or want snacks in between mealtimes. Here you can find lots of fresh produce and dairy items (that you can't import into the Bahamas), dry foods, toiletries, and supplies. In the back of the store you will find just about anything, from snorkeling gear and ice chests to towels. Hillside can also tell where and how to get fresh lobster, snapper, grouper, and more. There are seafood vendors living nearby.