Fodor's Expert Review Snug Harbor Resort

At this popular cottage resort and marina on the northwest side of the island, all of the units were completely rebuilt in 2014 with tall windows overlooking the water, high ceilings, well-equipped kitchens, knotty-pine wood paneling, gas fireplaces, and private decks. Each cottage sleeps up to four (even the one bedrooms have additional hideaway beds). You can book a kayak or whale-watching tour, leaving daily from the marina, and there's a small camp store and coffeehouse on-site.