Fodor's Expert Review La Caletta

For a bit more privacy, space, and a live-like-a-local vibe, try this small collection of houses, villas, and apartments. While each property has its own feel and design—and are scattered across the island—the chic Panarea vibe comes through with the fresh white walls, collection of Sicilian ceramics, and ample outdoor spaces with stunning sea views. Guests can visit partner Hotel Oasi for breakfast (€10).