New Providence and Paradise Islands Restaurants

Foodies will delight in New Providence's restaurant range, from shabby shacks serving up the kind of food you'd find in any Bahamian's kitchen, to elegant eateries where jackets are required and the food rivals that found in any major city. You'll recognize celebrity chef names like Todd English, Jean-Georges Vongerichten, and Nobu Matsuhisa, all of whom have restaurants on Paradise Island.

Eating out can get expensive, particularly in resort restaurants, so a budget-friendly strategy is having brunch at one of the myriad all-you-can-eat buffets at the larger hotels on Paradise Island and Cable Beach, then a light snack to hold you over until dinnertime.

Note: A gratuity (15%) is often added to the bill automatically.

Sort by: 23 Recommendations {{numTotalPoiResults}} {{ (numTotalPoiResults===1)?'Recommendation':'Recommendations' }} 0 Recommendations
CLEAR ALL Area Search CLEAR ALL
Loading...
  • 1. Athena Cafe and Bar

    $$

    You're greeted with a welcoming "Opa!" at this family-owned authentic Greek spot where they serve up tasty lunches at moderate prices. Sit on the second floor among Grecian statuary or on the balcony overlooking the action below. Enjoy souvlaki, moussaka, or a hearty Greek gyro, a break from the Nassau culinary routine, in a relaxed and friendly establishment. Be sure to save room for one of their authentic Greek desserts. The baklava cheesecake is divine. Dinner is an option only if you eat very early; they close at 5 pm.

    Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-326–1296

    Known For

    • The best Greek salad around
    • Flaming cheese
    • The cries of "Opa!" as guests walk in

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: No dinner; closed Sun.
  • 2. Bahamian Cookin' Restaurant

    $$

    Three generations of Bahamian women treat patrons as if they were guests in their own home. And the Bahamian food whipped up in the kitchen is as close to homemade as you can get in a restaurant. This simple locale is bustling with local professionals during the week and has also become a popular spot for cruise-ship passengers. Grandmother Mena swears their conch fritters are the "conchiest" you'll find. Takeout-only breakfast is served Monday through Saturday, while lunch is both sit-down and take-out the same days.

    Parliament St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-328–0334

    Known For

    • Home-style cooking
    • Tasty conch fritters
    • Friendly service

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun., No dinner
  • 3. Café Matisse

    $$$

    Low-slung settees, stucco arches, and reproductions of the eponymous artist's works set a casual and refined tone at this restaurant owned by a husband-and-wife team. He's Bahamian, she's northern Italian, and the fare perfectly blends the two cultures. Sit in the ground-floor garden under large white umbrellas or dine inside the century-old house for lunch or dinner. Start with the warm Parmesan terrine, then dive into freshly made pasta or risotto with prawns, or the filet drizzled with a mouth watering green peppercorn sauce. Be sure to save room for dessert and the delicious handmade cookies that come with coffee.

    Bank La. and Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-356–7012

    Known For

    • Italian cuisine with a Bahamian spin
    • Biannually changing menu
    • Delicious handmade cookies

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun., Mon., and Tues dinner; and Sept.
  • 4. Crusoe's Restaurant

    $$

    This hidden gem is worth a visit even if you are not staying at the Comfort Suites; the casual and family-friendly, alfresco restaurant has enticing menus. The lunch menu is available whenever the restaurant is open and offers a variety of sandwiches, wraps, and salads as well as delectable desserts. Their guava brioche bread pudding is something you must try. For dinner, there is something for everyone if you're looking for a more substantial meal. It's a great spot for seafood, but they also offer a variety of meat, chicken, and vegetarian dishes.

    Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-363–3680

    Known For

    • Casual setting with great service
    • Nice alternative to the larger, fancier Atlantis offerings
    • Guava brioche bread pudding
  • 5. Dune by Jean-Georges

    $$$$

    Feast on Jean-Georges Vongerichten's intricately prepared dishes while overlooking Cabbage Beach at the renowned Four Seasons Ocean Club. Go for breakfast or lunch for the most (relatively) reasonable prices. For breakfast, try the eggs Benedict or traditional Bahamian boiled fish. For dinner, share a Black Plate appetizer sampler featuring everything from crab spring rolls to chicken samosas to start, then end with one of their signature sweet treats like the delicious banana cake topped with caramelized banana slices or the decadent Dune Sundae: rice pudding ice cream, caramelized Rice Krispies and chocolate fudge. It's a great place to unwind amid ocean breezes.

    Ocean Club Dr., Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-363–2501

    Known For

    • Chef Jean-Georges's signature dishes
    • Fine dining overlooking the ocean
    • Divine salted caramel banana cake

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Reservations essential
  • Recommended Fodor’s Video

  • 6. Fifty-Fifty Grillers

    $

    Follow the plume of smoke wafting onto Shirley Street to find this roadside spot with some of the best jerk chicken, pork, and slow-grilled ribs around. It's open Friday and Saturday for takeout only; meals come with a fresh baked roll as well as pasta salad or corn on the cob or cajun fries. At $14 for chicken or pork and $16 for ribs, you can't find a better deal. Their native macaroni and cheese is worth the $3 upgrade. They also serve fried fish.

    Shirley St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-677–2833

    Known For

    • Best jerk pit around
    • Great value for money
    • Laid-back island vibe

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun.--Thurs.
  • 7. Graycliff Restaurant

    $$$$

    A meal at this hillside mansion's formal restaurant begins in the elegant parlor, where drinks are served over the sounds of a live piano. It's a rarefied world, where waiters wear tuxedos and Cuban cigars and cognac are served after dinner. Graycliff's signature dishes include Kobe beef, Kurobuta pork, and Nassau grouper. The wine cellar contains more than 200,000 bottles that have been hand-picked by owner Enrico Garzaroli, some running into the tens of thousands of dollars. There are plenty of less expensive bottles, but you'll find the markup on better vintages to be much less than what you'd find in a big-city restaurant almost anywhere in the world. You can even buy the world's oldest bottle of wine, a German vintage 1727, for $200,000. Mere mortals can settle for the weekday wine luncheons. For an extra-special dining experience, you can book the wine cellar's private dining room.

    W. Hill St. at Cumberland Rd., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-302–9150

    Known For

    • Only five-star rating in town
    • Signature Kobe beef
    • Third largest wine cellar in the world

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Reservations essential, Jacket required for dinner and no shorts permitted
  • 8. Lukka Kairi Waterfront Bar & Grill

    $$$

    For the best views of Nassau Harbour, dine at this quaint bar and restaurant. As you watch the cruise ships pulling in and out of the nearby port, you can sip on a frozen margarita and enjoy some of the best ceviche around.

    Woodes Rodgers Walk, Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-427--8886

    Known For

    • Mexican–Bahamian inspired menu
    • Spectacular 180-degree harbor views
    • Cool breezes and spectacular sunsets
  • 9. McKenzie's Conch Shack

    $

    You no longer have to venture over the bridge to get a bowl of authentic conch salad—this takeout shack in Marina Village makes conch salad to order. Pull up a bar stool and watch the dizzying display of knife skills it takes to make this local delicacy. Wash it down with a local beer or a sweet daiquiri.

    Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas

    Known For

    • Only fresh conch salad on Paradise Island
    • Daiquiri bar
    • Worth the long wait
  • 10. Syrah Cellar Cafe

    $$

    This intimate spot is usually packed with locals who reside on the eastern end of the island; be sure to call ahead to book a table. Dine surrounded by bottles of wine and, on some nights, live acoustic guitar. There's also an outdoor terrace. Choose from a variety of small plates: sweet-heat conch bites, BBQ pulled-pork poutine, and the grilled lobster crostini. There's also a selection of flatbreads, burgers, pasta dishes, and hearty meat and seafood entrees.

    E. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-676--0962

    Known For

    • Warm and friendly service and atmosphere
    • Eclectic menu
    • Impressive wine pairings

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun. and Mon.
  • 11. The Bearded Clam Sports Bar

    $

    Nestled in the middle of the International Arcade linking Bay Street and the wharf is this lively bar and restaurant serving up tasty appetizers and meals. Try the traditional Bahamian cracked conch or conch balls. If you're particularly hungry, order the gigantic burrito or Godzilla Burger. Wash it all down with something from the extensive drinks menu, and don't forget to sign your name on the wall before you leave. Kids are welcome, but the menu isn't the most kid-friendly.

    Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-323–4455

    Known For

    • Potent drinks with cheeky names
    • Tasty bar fare
    • Lively atmosphere

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: No dinner
  • 12. The New Duff

    $

    This funky little spot puts a unique Asian street-food twist on the guava duff, a traditional Bahamian dessert. Fluffy, handmade steamed bao buns filled with sticky sweet fillings like guava or caramelized coconut and smothered with traditional sauce are a must try, but they also serve savory bao buns filled with island flavors like jerk chicken, curried mutton, and ginger pork. Wash it down with a traditional bush tea, choosing your preferred level of sweetness. While you wait, check out the tiny museum display with interesting artifacts from The Family Islands of old.

    W. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-824--3000

    Known For

    • Delicious fusion street food
    • Bao bun guava duff
    • Variety of bush teas
  • 13. Viola's Bar & Grill

    $$

    This unassuming bar and grill is a consistent Paradise Island favorite with locals and savvy visitors. Their menu is a simple but tasty mix of standard American basics like burgers, pizza, sandwiches, and salads as well as Bahamian classics like curry chicken and conch fritters. Breakfast is strictly American style. The small al fresco bar and restaurant can get quite lively on weekends when the nightly karaoke gives way to professional live music.

    Casino Drive, Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-363–3739

    Known For

    • Lively vibe
    • Delicious Bahamian cooking
    • Frequented by locals and "in the know" visitors
  • 14. Wild Thyme Restaurant

    $$$

    Dine inside or on the wraparound porches of a two-story traditional wooden Bahamian home. The menu is small, but there are lots of classic dishes to choose from, including golden beet and tomato salad with feta and goat cheese, or the loaded grilled short-rib grilled cheese sandwich. Enjoy a fancy cocktail or a bottle of French wine from an impressive drinks menu, and finish up with the white chocolate guava bread pudding or Bahamian chocolate rum cake.

    33 E. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-393–4107

    Known For

    • Understated elegance
    • Generous portions
    • Classic and unique signature cocktails

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun.
  • 15. Anthony's

    $$

    This lively, casual spot is one of the most affordable places for breakfast, lunch, or dinner this side of Nassau Harbour, but that doesn't mean it's cheap. The baby back ribs with a homemade barbecue sauce are among the most popular on this Bahamian and American fare menu. The extensive menu (60-plus items to choose from) includes seafood pasta, grouper and salmon, steaks, burgers, ribs, and salads. 

    Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-363–3152

    Known For

    • One of few nonresort restaurants on P. I.
    • Extensive menu
    • Affordable (by P. I. standards) dining
  • 16. East Villa Restaurant

    $$$

    In a converted old Bahamian home, this is one of the most popular Chinese restaurants in town. The Chinese–continental menu includes entrées such as conch with black-bean sauce, hung shew (walnut chicken), and steak kew (cubed prime fillet served with baby corn, snow peas, water chestnuts, and vegetables). The New York strip steak is nirvana. A short taxi ride from Paradise Island or downtown Nassau, this is the perfect spot if you're seeking something a little different from the typical area restaurants.

    E. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-393–3377

    Known For

    • Traditional Chinese cuisine
    • Broiled NY strip steaks
    • Huge portions

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: No lunch Sat. or public holidays
  • 17. Hillside House

    $

    Tucked away in a courtyard off a busy street, you'll find this restaurant, bar, and art gallery all wrapped up in one. The gallery is housed in the 1840 back house—all that remains of an old Bahamian estate. Once you've had a look at the local art inside, take a seat at one of the long communal picnic tables in the courtyard and order a classic Bahamian cocktail like a Bahama Mama or Goombay Smash from the wooden shack bar or try one of their specialty cocktails infused with local flavors. Be sure to ask the bartender to explain the names of the drinks. The food is simple but delicious—wings, conch fritters, burgers, tacos, and nachos.

    13 Cumberland Street, Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-322--7678

    Known For

    • Cool, funky oasis
    • Refreshing Bahamian cocktails
    • Beautiful art gallery

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun. and Mon., Gallery admission $2
  • 18. Latitudes

    $$$

    Book one of Latitudes' teppanyaki tables for a delicious and entertaining dining experience. The chefs will cook your choice of a variety of meats and seafood on the hot grill as you look on in awe. Five different kitchens churn out a number of different cuisines to order. You can choose from pizza (try the meatball with basil cream), Alfredo shrimp, sushi, or ramen. There's also a steakhouse where you can indulge in 32 ounces of premium rib eye or porterhouse. The restaurant offers sweeping views of picturesque Nassau Harbour.

    E. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-676–8025

    Known For

    • Only spot for teppanyaki
    • Views of Nassau Harbour
    • International brunch on weekends
  • 19. Olives

    $$$$

    Todd English has paired up with Atlantis to give his signature Mediterranean style a taste of the Caribbean. Pick the fish you want to see on your plate or satisfy your meat craving with a steak or double cut pork chop. Situated right inside the lively Atlantis Casino, Olives is one of the few places to grab a late-night bite—the kitchen is open with a limited menu of their flavorful flatbreads and other staples until the wee hours of the night.

    Paradise Island, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-363–3000

    Known For

    • Late-night kitchen
    • Extensive flatbread offering
    • Homemade pasta dishes
  • 20. Seafront Sushi

    $$

    One of Nassau's hot spots, this simple restaurant has an extensive menu, including traditional rolls, sushi, and sashimi, as well as more innovative options that incorporate conch and other local delicacies. The volcano roll topped with their special conch sauce is a favorite. There are enough non-seafood options on the menu to satisfy anyone in your group. Friday and Saturday nights are really busy, and they do not accept reservations, so be prepared to wait for a table.

    E. Bay St., Nassau, New Providence Island, Bahamas
    242-394–1706

    Known For

    • Volcano roll
    • Sushi worth waiting for
    • Traditional tatami rooms

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: No lunch Sat., Reservations not accepted

No Restaurants Results

Please try a broader search, or expore these popular suggestions:

There are no results for {{ strDestName}} Restaurants in the searched map area with the above filters. Please try a different area on the map, or broaden your search with these popular suggestions:

Recommended Fodor’s Video